• Subscribe

    You have Successfully Subscribed!

NCAA Division 3 Women’s Top Lacrosse Players from Long Island

Caitlin Andersen - Photo Credit W and L

Talent is ALL OVER at the D3 level for the women. WIth so much talent spread out at so many different school, this list was tough to make up. LILJ looked at numerous criteria to select the players on this list. From stats and accolades, to academics and consistency, the players on this list have demonstrated all the qualities as to what it takes to be the not only the best from Long Island, but the best in the country.

1 Caitlin Anderson, Junior Defense Manhasset, W and L

Second Team All- ODAC selection, Anderson was a member of the All- Tournament team and pick up 37 ground balls on the season

2 Lilly Bernardi, Junior Defense, Massapequa, TCJN

Started all 23 games for the Lions and Led the nation in scoring defense.

3 Annika Johnsen, Senior Midfield, Bellport, Messiah

55 points on the year, securing 22 draw controls, Johnsen marked First Team All- Mac Commonwealth and First Team All- Metro

4 Collette Murray, Junior Attacker, Manhasset, W and L

Second Team All- ODAC registered 50 points on last years season

5 Corie Hack, Senior Attacker, ESM, Claremont Mckenna

SCIAC Offensive player of the year and First Team All- SCIAC, starting 20 games and amassed 70 points on the year.

Lily Bernardi - Photo Credit TCJN Athletics

6 Caroline Scaglione, Junior Defense, Friends Academy, Wesleyan

7 Brianna Hayes, Senior Midfield, St. Anthony’s W and L

8 Kate Calabro, Junior Midfield, Wantagh, Scranton

9 Melanie Bert, Junior Attacker, Oceanside, Widener

10 Kerry Mckeever, Sophomore Midfield, Ward Melville, Gettysburg

11 Kelsey Cohen, Senior Midfield, Baldwin, Oneonta

12 Kelly Siebert, Sophomore Defense, Syosset, Amherst

13 Carli Clementi, Senior Defense, Harborfields, Cortland

14 Elena Gallo, Senior Attack, Kellenberg, Scranton

15 Amanda Tullo, Senior Attacker, Smithtown West, Muhlenberg

16 Jennifer Cook, Senior Attacker, Manhasset, Trinity

17 Bizzer Gahagan, Junior Attacker, Portledge, William Smith

18 Lydia Nelson, Junior Goalie, Center Moriches, Roger Williams

19 Siobhan Warburton, Junior Midfield, Wantagh, Scranton

20 Kayla Buell, Junior Defense, Kings Park, Stevenson

21 Sarah Montalbano, Sophomore Defense, St. Anthony’s, Trinity

22 Katie Stallone, Senior Attacker, St. Anthony’s Springfield

23 Katie Buell, Junior Midfield, Kings Park, Stevens Tech

24 Haley Newberg, Senior Defense, Farmingdale

25 Holly Regan, Senior Attacker, Ward Melville, Catholic

Honorable Mention:

Morgan Graham, Senior Attack, Ward Melville, Kean


Leave a Reply

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Get everything lacrosse on the Island delivered straight to your email inbox each week!
Stay Updated
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.