• Subscribe

    You have Successfully Subscribed!

LILJ All-Long Island Girls Class of 2023

The LILJ saw so many talented players take the field this season in the class of 2023. Some of them got their first taste of playing on the varsity level after not getting the opportunity last year and certainly made the most of it. These girls were integral players to their team’s success this year and showed that both the present and the future is very bright as many of them will be recruited by top flight college lacrosse programs. We look forward to seeing these girls play for another two years in high school. Here are the first and second All-Long Island teams as well as the honorable mentions created by the LILJ! If any of these amazing players commit starting September 1st, be sure to update the LILJ so we can promote their accomplishments.

LILJ All-Long Island 1st Team

Name Position School
Haydin Eisfeld Attack Bayport
Delaney Radin Attack Long Beach
Lea Flobeck Attack Mount Sinai
Eva Ingrilli Attack Wantagh
Madison Alaimo Attack Wantagh
Keira Rooney Attack/Midfield Bayport
Maggie Kennedy Attack/Midfield Bayport
Kate Timarky Attack/Midfield Middle Country
Madison Weybrecht Defense Bayport
Brianna Wendling Defense Bethpage
Brooke Meltcher Defense SWR
Caityblu Cavassa Draw Lynbrook
Felicia Giglio Goalie Bayport
Shae Lembo Goalie St. Anthony’s
Katie Clare Midfield Bayport
Alyssa Deacy Midfield Comsewogue
Paris Panagopoulous Midfield Friends Academy
Caitlin Barrett Midfield Manhasset
Bridget Valentine Midfield Massapequa
Joely Caramelli Midfield Massapequa
Kylee Colbert Midfield North Shore
Ava Arceri Midfield Smithtown East
Lacey Downey Midfield West Babylon

All-Long Island 2nd Team

Name Position School
Mikaela Mooney Attack Bayport
Sara Curley Attack Lynbrook
Mimi Berkowitz Attack Lynbrook
Taylor Cline Attack Mount Sinai
Frankie Gray Attack Sacred Heart
Taylor Hoss Attack Sayville
Kelsey Restivo Attack Sayville
Jaimey Hill Attack/Midfield West Islip
Mia Fernandes Defense Comsewogue
Taylor Sturtz Defense East Islip
Laurel Bonn Defense Huntington
Sophie Mellman Defense Longwood
Abby Sabella Defense Mount Sinai
Olivia Redden Defense Sayville
Amanda Ettinger Defense Seaford
Emily Murtha Defense William Floyd
Grace McCarthy Draw Northport
Olivia Bradley Goalie Commack
Alexa Kuhn Goalie Rocky Point
Gabby Constant Midfield Comsewogue
Carly Livingston Midfield Farmingdale
Marie Cacciabaudo Midfield Garden City
Meg Morrisroe Midfield St. Dominic’s
Gianna Forte Midfield Huntington
Payton Tini Midfield Locust Valley
Emma McLam Midfield Northport
Graceanne Leonard Midfield SWR
Jess Giller Midfield/Attack Massapequa
Bella Lanza Midfield/Defense Commack
Bryn Gardiner Midfield/Defense Mattituck

LILJ All-Long Island Honorable Mentions

Team Name Position School
HM Kailyn Salony Attack Bethpage
HM Madison Traversa Attack Bethpage
HM Sofia Mescolotto Attack Calhoun
HM Lauryn Spivak Attack Center Moriches
HM Megan Magill Attack Center Moriches
HM Ashley Kolomechuk Attack Commack
HM Kacey McCrary Attack Comsewogue
HM Lindsey Radmann Attack Comsewogue
HM Gianna Giacolone Attack ESM
HM Mia Forte Attack ESM
HM Grace Hopkins Attack Garden City
HM Avery Falco Attack Islip
HM Alexa Preston Attack Longwood
HM Tatum Goettelmann Attack Manhasset
HM Caitlyn Dorman Attack Massapequa
HM Ellie Leisen Attack Massapequa
HM Kate Ciarlo Attack Massapequa
HM Ella Suglia Attack Mattituck
HM Megan Tobin Attack Mattituck
HM Kaitlyn Ippolito Attack Middle Country
HM Daniela Martini Attack North Shore
HM Ava Bartoli Attack North Shore
HM Megan Checola Attack Oceanside
HM Abbey D’Elia Attack St. Anthony’s
HM Olivia Nicholson Attack Wantagh
HM Samantha Shaumloffel Attack Westhampton
HM Sabrina Doyle Attack Westhampton
HM Ava Lopez Attack Longwood
HM Haleigh Greenberg Attack Northport
HM Olivia Annunziata Attack Middle Country
HM Sia Markowski Attack/Midfield Harborfields
HM Julianna Nabet Attack/Midfield Locust Valley
HM Madison Dusold Attack/Midfield Locust Valley
HM Sage Foster Attack/Midfield Mattituck
HM Lauren Matyka Attack/Midfield Riverhead
HM Liz Hanham Attack/Midfield Riverhead
HM Christine Dannenfelser Defense Bayport
HM Mackenzie Bracken Defense Bethpage
HM Avery Laffery Defense Cold Spring Harbor
HM Gianna Cardillo Defense West Hempstead
HM Giana Demartino Defense Commack
HM Katelyn Greeley Defense Manhasset
HM Alexandra Schneider Defense Manhasset
HM Cat Leder Defense Manhasset
HM Alexa Cirabisi Defense Massapequa
HM Bridget Carlson Defense Harborfields
HM Mary Koster Defense Massapequa
HM Mia Juvelier Defense Middle Country
HM Nicole Yerys Defense Whitman
HM Eliza Ritter Defense North Shore
HM Maya Best Defense North Shore
HM Gillian Lefcourt Defense Port Washington
HM Olivia Van Dyke Defense Rocky Point
HM Haley Chandler Defense Sachem East
HM Ali Howell Defense Sachem East
HM Mackenzie Reilly Defense Sachem North
HM Blair Davi Defense St. Anthony’s
HM Lindsay Langella Defense SWR
HM Catie Edson Defense Ward Melville
HM Emilie Schultz Defense Rocky Point
HM Jess Rosen Goalie Center Moriches
HM Cecelia Van Blenis Goalie Garden City
HM Ava Guigliano Goalie Hewlett
HM Katelyn Hicks Goalie Islip
HM Elani Correa Goalie Longwood
HM Megan Morris Goalie Northport
HM Lauren Rochel Goalie Wantagh
HM Nicole Schaumloffel Goalie Wantagh
HM Piper Mascaros Goalie John Glenn
HM Mary Kate Nawrocki Midfield Bethpage
HM Nicole Dux Midfield Bethpage
HM Juliana Talenti Midfield Bethpage
HM Charlotte Castiglione Midfield Center Moriches
HM Jennifer Albert Midfield Cold Spring Harbor
HM Hannah Van Son Midfield Cold Spring Harbor
HM Danielle McGuire Midfield Comsewogue
HM Isabella Pota Midfield East Meadow
HM Brianna Bellando Midfield Farmingdale
HM Ariana Bransfield Midfield Garden City
HM Olivia Piazzolo Midfield Islip
HM Rebecca Reinhardt Midfield Longwood
HM Kaelynn O’Brien Midfield Lynbrook
HM Ashley Melillo Midfield Massapequa
HM Juliana Sepziale Midfield Middle Country
HM Alexa Ayotte Midfield Port Jefferson
HM Natalie Demeo Midfield Port Washington
HM Mary Kate Abernathy Midfield Rocky Point
HM Brooke Grossjung Midfield Holy Trinity
HM Kasi Samuda Midfield Holy Trinity
HM Isabella Dembinski Midfield Sachem East
HM Anna Meserve Midfield Sayville
HM Emma Cawley Midfield Smithtown East
HM Demmerle Hamel Midfield South Side
HM Hailey Ferraro-Reich Midfield South Side
HM Kate Licciardi Midfield St. Anthony’s
HM Ava McCormick Midfield Stony Brook
HM Abigail Beran Midfield SWR
HM Annie Sheehan Midfield SWR
HM Julia Nicholson Midfield Wantagh
HM Faith Donaghy Midfield Wantagh
HM Nicole Baudo Midfield Wantagh
HM Reilly Mahon Midfield Westhampton
HM Julia Charvat Midfield Pat Med
HM Kaylie Sullivan Midfield Islip
HM Emily Herbert Midfield/Defense Bethpage


  1. Karen Caramelli says:

    Thank you guys ! Always amazed at the amount of time and effort you put into our LI Girls and getting So many names out there. Means a lot to those who don’t always get recognized.

  2. Ted Wendling says:

    A lot of top talent on this list all around!

Leave a Reply

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Get everything lacrosse on the Island delivered straight to your email inbox each week!
Stay Updated
Give it a try, you can unsubscribe anytime.