The playoffs are here and there has been no shortage of talent in the senior class. Since we’re headed to a close on the 2023 season, it’s that time of the year to start looking at contenders for the annual Girls Paumanok Award. The honor is meant to recognize the best player on Long Island who has exhibited leadership, productivity and excellence on and off the field. Last year’s recipient, Madison Taylor went on to Northwestern University and has excelled as a freshman. The winner of this year’s Paumanok Award will be announced at the All-Long Island Games on June 19th at the conclusion of the senior game. Who will be crowned as this year’s winner? Let’s take a look at this year’s senior candidates for the 2023 Girls Paumanok Award.
| Name | School |
| Christine Dannenfelser | Bayport |
| Felicia Giglio | Bayport |
| Haydin Eisfeld | Bayport |
| Katie Clare | Bayport |
| Madison Weybrecht | Bayport |
| Maggie Kennedy | Bayport |
| Mikaela Mooney | Bayport |
| Brianna Wendling | Bethpage |
| Emily Herbert | Bethpage |
| Juliana Talenti | Bethpage |
| Mary Kate Nawrocki | Bethpage |
| Nicole Dux | Bethpage |
| Sofia Mescolotto | Calhoun |
| Charlotte Castiglione | Center Moriches |
| Jess Rosen | Center Moriches |
| Lauryn Spivak | Center Moriches |
| Megan Magill | Center Moriches |
| Hannah Van Son | Cold Spring Harbor |
| Ashley Kolomechuk | Commack |
| Bella Lanza | Commack |
| Alyssa Deacy | Comsewogue |
| Gabby Constant | Comsewogue |
| Lindsay Radmann | Comsewogue |
| Mia Fernandes | Comsewogue |
| Brooke Elizalde | Connetquot |
| Isabella Pota | East Meadow |
| Gianna Giacolone | ESM |
| Mia Forte | ESM |
| Alena Godas | Farmingdale |
| Briana Bellando | Farmingdale |
| Carly Livingston | Farmingdale |
| Paris Panagopoulos | Friends Academy |
| Ariana Bransfield | Garden City |
| Grace Hopkins | Garden City |
| Marie Cacciabaudo | Garden City |
| Sia Markowski | Harborfields |
| Ava Guigliano | Hewlett |
| Gianna Forte | Huntington |
| Laurel Bonn | Huntington |
| Piper Mascaros | John Glenn |
| Anne McGovern | Kings Park |
| Jaxie Cestone | Kings Park |
| Mary Ellen Gilchrist | Kings Park |
| Olivia Deltatto | Locust Valley |
| Payton Tini | Locust Valley |
| Delaney Radin | Long Beach |
| Caityblu Cavassa | Lynbrook |
| Kaelynn O’Brien | Lynbrook |
| Mimi Berkorwitz | Lynbrook |
| Sara Curley | Lynbrook |
| Smithtown West | Madison Driscoll |
| Alexandra Schneider | Manhasset |
| Caitlin Barrett | Manhasset |
| Ashley Melillo | Massapequa |
| Bridget Valentine | Massapequa |
| Jess Giller | Massapequa |
| Joely Caramelli | Massapequa |
| Mary Koster | Massapequa |
| Brynn Gardner | Mattituck |
| Ella Suglia | Mattituck |
| Megan Tobin | Mattituck |
| Sage Foster | Mattituck |
| Kate Timarky | Middle Country |
| Mia Juvelier | Middle Country |
| Natalia Altebrando | Miller Place |
| Abby Sabella | Mount Sinai |
| Lea Flobeck | Mount Sinai |
| Sarah Flobeck | Mount Sinai |
| Taylor Cline | Mount Sinai |
| Ava Bartoli | North Shore |
| Kylee Colbert | North Shore |
| Emma McLam | Northport |
| Grace McCarthy | Northport |
| Haleigh Greenberg | Northport |
| Megan Morris | Northport |
| Megan Checola | Oceanside |
| Natalie Demeo | Port Washington |
| Liz Hanham | Riverhead |
| Grace Curtin | Rocky Point |
| MaryKate Abernethy | Rocky Point |
| Isabella Dembinski | Sachem East |
| Anna Meserve | Sayville |
| Kelsey Restivo | Sayville |
| Olivia Redden | Sayville |
| Taylor Hoss | Sayville |
| Amanda Ettinger | Seaford |
| Ava Arceri | Smithtown East |
| Demmerle Hamel | South Side |
| Blair Davi | St. Anthony’s |
| Bridget Darcy | St. Anthony’s |
| Kate Licciardi | St. Anthony’s |
| Sam DiCarlo | St. Anthony’s |
| Shae Lembo | St. Anthony’s |
| Meg Morrisroe | St. Dominic |
| Abigail Beran | SWR |
| Brooke Meltcher | SWR |
| Graceann Leonard | SWR |
| Lindsay Langella | SWR |
| Julia Nicholson | Wantagh |
| Madison Alaimo | Wantagh |
| Nicole Baudo | Wantagh |
| Olivia Nicholson | Wantagh |
| Catie Edson | Ward Melville |
| Lacey Downey | West Babylon |
| Jaimey Hill | West Islip |
| Isabella Blanco | Westhampton |
| Reilly Mahon | Westhampton |
| Emily Murtha | William Floyd |
