LILJ Girls All-Winter League Teams

The 2022-2023 LILJ Girls HSWL was filled with many top tier varsity teams on the island as well as elite level club teams and JV teams showcasing the depth that programs have. With the winter league having come to an end and a bevy of players who played at a high level, the LILJ has put together a first and second All-Winter League Team along with honorable mentions. Despite some players not being able to play in every game, in the small sample size that they were on the field, they had a tremendous impact on the game and were still eligible for either of the teams. Each team has been created based on position and graduating year between the classes of 2023-2026. Check out each All-Winter League Team down below!

Class of 2023 First Team

Attack Maddie Alaimo (Wantagh) Taylor Cline (Mt. Sinai) Haydin Eisfield (Bayport) Lea Flobeck (Mt. Sinai) Mikaela Mooney (Bayport) Olivia Nicholson (Wantagh) Midfield Ava Arceri (Smithtown East) Katie Clare (Bayport) Alyssa Deacy (Comsewogue) Julia Nicholson (Wantagh) Defense Christine Dannenfelser (Bayport) Mia Fernandes (Comsewogue) Brooke Meltcher (SWR) Maddie Weybrecht (Bayport) Goalie Felicia Giglio (Bayport)

Class of 2023 Second Team

Attack Grace Curtin (Rocky point) Katie Gavin (Garden City) Gianna Giacolone (ESM) Grace Hopkins (Garden City) Kacey McGorry (St. Anthony’s 23) Midfield MaryKate Abernethy (Rocky Point) Abby Beran (SWR) Marie Cacciabado (Garden City) Gabby Constant (Comsewogue) Bridget Darcy (St. Anthony’s 23) Mia Forte (ESM) GraceAnn Leonard (SWR) Reilly Mahon (Westhampton) Keira Rooney (Bayport) Defense  Catie Edson (Ward Melville) Rory Heslin (Garden City) Lindsay Radmann (Comsewogue) Abby Sabella (Mt. Sinai) Goalie Natalia Altebrando (Miller Place)

Class of 2023 Honorable Mention

Attack  Kate Licciardi (St. Anthony’s 23) Cassidy Millen (Mt. Sinai) Annie Sheehan (SWR) Kristin Vosswinkel (Ward Melville) Midfield Ellie Andersen (Garden City) Sam DiCarlo (St. Anthony’s 23) Maggie Kennedy (Bayport) Defense  Isabella Blanco (Westhampton) Sarah Blandi (Mt. Sinai) Paige Martin (Wantagh) Goalie  Sara Flobeck (Mt. Sinai) Alexa Kuhn (Rocky Point) Cece Van Blenis (Garden City)

Class of 2024 First Team

Attack  Grace Balocca (Ward Melville) McKenzie Moeller (Rocky Point) Jenna Soto (Smithtown East) Kate Spinks (Ward Melville) Midfield Tess Calabria (St. Anthony’s 24) Emily Haugen (St. Anthony’s 24) Megan Kenny (St. Anthony’s 24) Defense  Olivia Comerford (Ward Melville) Maddie Morris (St. Anthony’s 24) Chloe Mosher (Westhampton) Mabel Overbeck (Garden City) Goalie  Stella Quilty (St. Anthony’s 24)

Class of 2024 Second Team 

Attack  Casey Gilbert (Miller Place) Caylin Luciano (ESM) Kassidy Miller (Miller Place) Grace Mulham (Ward Melville) Jayden Piraino (Smithtown East) Riley Zusi (St. Anthony’s 24) Midfield Jena Binkis (St. Anthony’s 24) Kayli Carannante (Mt. Sinai) Julia Fusco (Bayport) Emilia Retzlaff (Ward Melville) Defense  Emily Ambrozy (St. Anthony’s 24) Sophia Conti (Smithtown East) Julia Kroog (Bayport) Kate McConnachie (St. Anthony’s 24) Goalie  Ashley Langdon (ESM)

Class of 2024 Honorable Mention

Attack Maureen Arendt (Garden City) Peyton Choma (Mt. Sinai) Riley Forthofer (Wantagh) Shannon Kroog (Bayport) Midfield Olivia Coffey (Miller Place) Sienna Diglio (Wantagh) Holly Hardwick (St. Anthony’s 24) Katie Lanning (Westhampton) Brooke Long (St. Anthony’s 24) Emma McLean (ESM) Kendall Morris (Garden City) Amelia Pirozzi (Ward Melville) Alexis Savage (Smithtown East) Amanda Sweeney (ESM) MJ Timpanaro (Ward Melville) Anna Wood (Rocky Point) Defense  Madison Hall (Miller Place) Kenzie Schindler (Westhampton) Goalie  Shannon Alden (Bayport) Ava Carillo (Ward Melville) Niamh Pfaff (Garden City)

Class of 2025 First Team

Attack Mirabella Altebrando (Miller Place) Kyle Finnell (Garden City/YJ Spallina) Alexa Spallina (Mt. Sinai/YJ Spallina) Kate Theofield (Smithtown West) Midfield Aubrie Eisfeld (Bayport/YJ Spallina) Cady Flaherty (YJ Spallina) Reese King (Westhampton/YJ Spallina) Ava Meyn (Bayport/YJ Spallina) Tori Ottomanelli (Garden City) Jolie Schiavo (Smithtown West/YJ Spallina) Defense  Emma Brown (Bayport/YJ Spallina) Julia May O’Connor (YJ Spallina) Peyton Phillips (Ward Melville/YJ Spallina) Ava Schirtzer (Mt. Sinai/YJ Spallina) Goalie  Maya Farnan (Westhampton)

Class of 2025 Second Team

Attack Ava Clark (Mt. Sinai/YJ Spallina) Arci Haffner (Garden City) Grayce Kitchen (SWR) Reese Marcario (SWR/YJ Spallina) Brie Provenzano (Westhampton) Midfield Lily Graves (Westhampton) Molly Hiney (YJ Spallina) Kylie Lamoureux (Rocky Point) Ava Simonton (Ward Melville/YJ Spallina) Fiona Vu (Rocky Point) Hayden Young (Miller Place) Defense  Hailey Donohoe (Westhampton) Ava Folkman (Ward Melville) Violet Freebody (Rocky Point) Lyla Ingrilli (Wantagh) Abigail LoNigro (Miller Place/YJ Spallina) Goalie  Jess Black (YJ Spallina) Breezy Henke (YJ Spallina)

Class of 2025 Honorable Mention

Attack  Emily Clemens (YJ Spallina) Charlotte Erb (SWR) Erika Kreuscher (Bayport/YJ Spallina) Jackie Riviezzo (Comsewogue) Midfield Haylie Abrams (SWR) Amelia Brite (YJ Spallina) Sofia Cangelosi (YJ Spallina) Morgan Lesiewicz (SWR) Meghan Lynch (Garden City) Aubrey Maurer (YJ Spallina) Kathryn Monaco (Garden City) Kyla Orlando (Mt. Sinai/YJ Spallina) Natalie Psaltis (ESM) Isabella Sandoval (Wantagh) Defense  Brooke Hopkins (YJ Spallina) Kate Kadletz (SWR) Goalie Ryan Dart (Smithtown East) Kat Dietz (ESM)

Class of 2026 First Team

Attack  Kate Atkinson (YJ Manning) Grace Hoffman (YJ Manning) Sky Kilfeather (YJ Manning) Gianna McNulty (Comsewogue) Midfield Caitlin Barnes (YJ Manning) Kailey Bruckner (Bayport 2) Sophia Buffardi (YJ Manning) Ava Derby (Westhampton/YJ Manning) Defense  Shannon Carney (Bayport 2) Olivia DeSimone (YJ Manning) Emma Greenberg (YJ Manning) Kaleigh Renkowski (YJ Manning) Goalie  Maribella Marciano (Smithtown West)

Class of 2026 Second Team

Attack Sofia Amodemo (Westhampton JV) Eva Carvalho (Bayport 2) Alyssa Lorefice (YJ Manning) Sophia Masone (Mt. Sinai/YJ Manning) Kaleigh Moeller (Rocky Point/YJ Manning) Lillian Wood (Rocky Point) Midfield  Regan Backer (Garden City/YJ Manning) Ashley Mennella (Smithtown West) Kamryn McCrary (Comsewogue) Sara Richardt (Bayport 2) Defense  Abby Bishop (Bayport 2) Caroline Hoschel (YJ Manning) Morgan Farrell (YJ Manning) Goalie  Abigail Dieumegard (YJ Manning)

Class of 2026 Honorable Mention

Attack Ashley Clark (YJ Manning) Mischa Fernandes (Comsewogue) Alexa Guinther (SWR) Juliana Montalto (YJ Manning) Midfield  Sabrina Asadurian (Wantagh) Dagny Beasley (Westhampton JV) Maiya Boughal (Westhampton JV) Ava Failla (Westhampton JV) Anabel Keegan (SWR) Kady Keegan (SWR) Shannon Killoran (Westhampton JV) Nikki Lee (Westhampton JV) Ashlynn Renkowski (Smithtown West/YJ Manning) Claudia Retzlaff (Ward Melville JV) Defense  Caden Dorn (Westhampton JV) Meghan Langton (YJ Manning) Paige Manning (YJ Manning) Reese Wallace (YJ Manning) Goalie  Delany Florio (Ward Melville JV) Julia Lilienthal (YJ Manning) Gianna Ruggero (SWR)